The Downward DNA Spiral
Wednesday, September 5th, 2007 | This post was written by StephenThe call from Lord Justice Sedley for the whole population of the UK – and even foreign tourists on weekend breaks – to have their DNA stored on the national DNA database is a chilling proposal.
His Lordship makes the logical argument that the database we have at the moment – which includes samples from people who have come into contact with the police, but not from those who haven’t – is less useful and defensible than a comprehensive one. But his conclusion – that ‘everybody, guilty or innocent’ should have their DNA stored on it – is heading in the wrong direction. If anything, we should be worrying about the stealth and speed with which the database has grown since its inception.
- In 1995, when it was introduced, only the DNA of convicted criminals could be kept on the database.
- In 2001, Labour changed the law so that the DNA of people who had been acquitted of certain offences could still be kept.
- In 2004, they changed the law again so that anyone arrested and detained at a police station – whether or not they were even charged with a criminal offence – could have a DNA sample taken.
We have arrived at a situation where people detained for even minor offences, like political protests or speeding, have their DNA kept indefinitely. The UK now holds DNA profiles of a higher proportion of its population – 5.2 per cent – than any other country in the world. That’s over four million people. In the USA, the comparable figure is just 0.5 per cent.
When we already have the most draconian laws in the world, and given this Government’s lamentable record on big IT projects (remember the NHS national computer? Or the Passport Service? Or the Child Support Agency? Or the Rural Payments Agency…?), we should take a very deep pause for breath, rather than extend the scheme as dramatically as Lord Justice Sedley proposes.
Thankfully, the Home Office has reacted coolly to today’s suggestion. But Tony McNulty’s comment that ‘no-one ever says never’ is rather ominous. And forgive me if I don’t trust this Government to stand up for civil liberties.
Posts


